Judge rules for OREPA, et al.

Chief District Judge Pamela Reeves today issued a ruling in OREPA’s legal challenge to the UPF bomb plant. While she stopped short of requiring the National Nuclear Security Administration to prepare a new Environmental Impact Statement, she did rule that the government was required to prepare some new environmental analysis.

And on the way to getting there, she stripped the government’s authority to continue construction of the UPF bomb plant, vacating its 2016 Amended Record of Decision which authorized the latest version of the bomb plant”several new buildings and two old buildings.

Reeves noted it was unlikely that a more significant NEPA lawsuit was likely to come through the Knoxville courthouse. She broke the plaintiffs’ case into four parts, and found for the government on two parts and for co-plaintiffs OREPA, Nuclear Watch New Mexico, the Natural Resources Defense Council, Jack Hoefer, Ed Sullivan, Linda Ewald and Ralph Hutchison on two others, including the crucial question of the adequacy of NEPA documentation for the bomb plant.

The court issued a 104 page opinion. You can read it by scrolling down the sidebar to the right until you come to UPF lawsuit documents and clicking on the link to the ruling.

The decision is the fruit of a long process and the investment of thousands of dollars by hundreds of supporters who believed in the case enough to support it financially.

“We could never have done this without the power of deeply committed people who came together determined to stop the bomb plant. This is an incredibly important step in that effort,” said Ralph Hutchison, OREPA coordinator.

It is not clear whether the government will appeal the decision.

Resources:

Sunday Vigil at Y-12 in Oak Ridge Tennessee

Sunday Vigil

The OREPA Board has now decided that we are prepared to do a limited re-opening of the Sunday vigil to allow for slightly more participation.  We are asking anyone who wants to attend a Sunday vigil to sign up in advance—by the Thursday before. There are two ways to sign up. You can email Ralph at orep@earthlink.net or you can call him at 865 776 5050. If the five slots are already taken, we’ll ask you to wait until next week. All vigilers are expected to wear masks. Bring your own chair. Avoid physical contact and maintain an appropriate social distance in the circle of chairs. Of course, if for any reason you feel you may have been exposed to the virus or to someone with the virus, you should not attend the vigil. At this point, we are not resuming our monthly potlucks.

Learn More »
Where Should I park? vigil-map.jpg

Please Share!

Share on facebook
Facebook
Share on twitter
Twitter
Share on linkedin
LinkedIn